https://www.semesteratsea.org/In 2008, I arrived in Canada as an international student, full of hope and excitement. I was awarded a full scholarship to study Ethnomusicology at the University of Alberta. It was a dream come true, an opportunity to immerse myself in a new culture, expand my academic horizons, and contribute to the rich tapestry of Canadian society. Sixteen years later, despite my contributions and continuous efforts, I still do not have my permanent residency.
The journey has been far from smooth. The promise of a welcoming and inclusive Canada has often felt like a mirage, overshadowed by the harsh realities of a colonial-capitalist immigration system. This system, deeply entrenched in its ways, has perpetuated cycles of uncertainty, anxiety, and burnout.
The Colonial-Capitalist System at Play
The Canadian immigration system, like many others, is a product of its colonial past and capitalist present. It prioritizes economic contributions over human dignity, treating immigrants as mere cogs in the economic machine rather than as individuals with dreams, aspirations, and needs. This approach often leads to a dehumanizing experience, where the worth of an individual is measured by their economic output rather than their inherent value as a person.
The Burnout
Navigating this system has taken a toll on my mental and emotional well-being. The constant uncertainty of my immigration status has overshadowed many aspects of my life. Despite my academic achievements, professional contributions, and active engagement in the community, the lack of a clear pathway to permanent residency has been a persistent source of stress and burnout.
As a graduate student, I worked for several years as a teaching and research assistant. However, the specific requirements of Canadian immigration, which included two years of part-time continuous experience in a single role, invalidated most of my work. The roles changed from one semester to another, rendering my experience insufficient for immigration purposes. Upon graduation, there was no full-time job waiting for me. The Faculty of Extension offered me a single course, paying a meager wage of $1200 for 10 weeks.
In search of better opportunities, I joined Semester at Sea as Music Faculty. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, I couldn't return to Canada for two years. Upon re-entry, I put myself in the Express Entry pool, yet I still haven't heard back. The preference for permanent residents in job applications has further hindered my chances of securing a role. In 2022, I began part-time work as an Artist in Residence. While this experience did not count towards Express Entry either, I finally paid a fee of $2600 in 2023 to apply as a self-employed artist, considering my considerable accomplishments in recent years. The waiting period for that is over four years.
The barriers extend beyond the immigration process. Most artist grants, such as those from Canada Council and FACTOR, are available only to permanent residents. I can't travel to the US for performances either.
In 2024, I launched a social enterprise, The Deep Listening Path, not as a route to permanent residency but because I could not secure a job in Canada. Six months after establishing The Deep Listening Path, I decided to apply for the provincial nomination in the graduate entrepreneurship stream. I submitted an Expression of Interest and paid $200. My EOI was accepted. The next fee to pay is $3500 for the application, but prior to that, one needs an assessment of their business and net worth from a choice of two Canadian immigration companies. It was not mentioned on the website that their cost is not covered in the $3500. Upon calling, I found out that they charge $7000-$10,000 for the business assessment and $5000-$7000 for the net worth assessment.
This is how Alberta’s Provincial Nomination Program treats its graduates. Despite holding two degrees from the University of Alberta, I am being asked to pay exorbitant fees for assessments. Living a low-income life in Canada, I am highly disappointed in the Canadian immigration system and society.
Despite these challenges, I have continued to contribute to Canadian society. I have performed twice for the Canadian Citizenship ceremony, won the Cultural Diversity Award and Women in Music Honor Roll, and performed recently for MAP the Systems Canada Finals. It was at this event that a presentation on the inequities in treating international graduates, and the common thread of giving them piecemeal jobs that hinder their chances of receiving PR in Canada, inspired me to write this essay.
In 2022, the City of Edmonton advertised a job for which I did three rounds of interviews. By December 2022, they asked for a police check, and I inquired about the status of my application. They called me to share that the job was not a full-time position as advertised. The woman apologized profusely, explaining that the job was contingent upon enrollment in courses, meaning the income was not guaranteed. She advised me not to leave Calgary if I was settled there, as the job would not be worth it. Such a waste of time and energy.
The Canadian government does not take responsibility for how it treats international graduates. The common theme I have heard is to marry a Canadian, as it is the fastest route to permanent residency. In my ten years of living in Canada, I have found that my original community, the South Asian community, suffers from a deep internalized racism towards immigrants, especially immigrant women. Having suffered the impact of physical and emotional abuse from a South Asian Ismaili man from my community early on in my life, I do not wish to drag myself into a relationship where I see the man is incapable of handling my brilliance.
A Call for Change
My story is a testament to the urgent need for reform in the Canadian immigration system. It is time to move beyond a system that values economic contributions over human dignity. Canada prides itself on being a multicultural, inclusive society, yet its immigration policies often tell a different story.
We need an immigration system that recognizes and values the diverse contributions of immigrants, not just in economic terms but in cultural, social, and intellectual terms as well. A system that provides clear, accessible pathways to permanent residency, reducing the chronic stress and burnout experienced by so many.
Moving Forward
As I continue my journey in Canada, I remain hopeful for change. I am committed to using my voice and platform to advocate for a more humane and just immigration system. One that aligns with the values of inclusivity and respect that Canada stands for.
My work as an artist, researcher, and community advocate is deeply intertwined with my experiences as an immigrant. I will continue to challenge the colonial-capitalist structures and work towards a future where every immigrant is treated with the dignity and respect they deserve.
The journey is far from over, but together, we can pave the way for a more inclusive and compassionate Canada.
******
Dr. Shumaila Hemani is an artist, researcher, and community advocate specializing in energy affordability and certified training in positive neuroplasticity. Her work focuses on eco-art, integrating BIPOC narratives, and disrupting colonial and capitalist structures.